Compared: Tmall, Yihaodian and JD.com
China has the world’s largest eCommerce market. With over US$458 billion in sales in 2014 and global eCommerce sites controlling a market share of over 92 per cent, foreign engagement with the Chinese online retail sector is at a premium.
Tmall is China’s largest online marketplace dedicated to domestic and international branded merchandise. Owned by Alibaba Group, Tmall provides a marketplace for foreign brands to open exclusive shopfronts. Tmall Global, launched in 2013, sells only imported goods, and allows international brands without a physical presence in China to sell directly to Chinese consumers.
However, Tmall Global now operates via an invitation-only policy where only qualified merchants are either invited to join or can apply through a certified third party agency (TP). Consequently, the necessity of TP cooperation has complicated the process of setting up a store on the Tmall Global platform. For foreign companies looking to establish an online store without a physical presence, JD Worldwide is an increasingly more attractive option.
- A registered corporate entity outside of mainland China
- Possess retail and trade qualifications overseas
- Be the brand owner or authorized agency or possess the purchase voucher
- Possess the relevant stock certificate
Tmall Global targets:
- Corporations that have been operating for more than two years with annual sales over US$10 million;
- Branded B2C overseas businesses; and
- Brand owners or authorised agencies.
Selling point: Tmall Global provides merchants with an eCommerce platform and various marketing tools to help increase traffic and generate sales.
Warehouse: Tmall Global cooperates with certain Free Trade Zones in China to provide select merchants with a bonded warehouse service.
Logistics: Merchants must either ship packages directly from overseas, or store their products in a bonded warehouse in China for shipment to consumers. A Chinese address is mandatory to facilitate product return.
- Security Deposit – US$25,000
- Technical Fee – US$5,000 or US$10,000, per annum
- Commission – 0.5 per cent-5 per cent plus 1 per cent Alipay fee
Suitable for: Large international brands with demonstrated potential to achieve a large volume of sales or high revenue.
Hypermarkets, such as JD and Yihaodian, allow independent merchants to list products or operate shopfronts. Online hypermarkets are vertically integrated, multi-category marketplaces that purchase directly from suppliers for sale through their own network. These hypermarkets operate a proprietary online eCommerce platform and an in-house logistics network offering same-day delivery.
Selling to a hypermarket is done via negotiation with a procurement manager. Exporters are not required to manage distribution or a shopfront, but must provide official marketing collateral to promote their products.
JD is China’s largest online direct sales company. It owns and operates seven fulfillment centers and 166 warehouses in 44 cities, with a further 4142 delivery stations in 2043 counties and districts across China. JD allows merchants to open individual shopfronts and is licensed to import food, beverage products, apparel and shoes directly from overseas. JD’s cross-border service, JD Worldwide, enables merchants to sell directly to Chinese consumers without a Chinese presence.
JD distinguishes itself from Tmall Global via active global promotion of JD Worldwide (particularly in the US and Australia) and provision of a leading in-house logistics service. Furthermore, JD boasts a zero tolerance policy with regard to counterfeit products.
- Registered corporate identity outside mainland China, with registration capital of over RMB500,000;
- Possess retail and trade qualifications overseas;
- Be the brand owner or authorised agency or possess the purchase voucher; and
- Possess the relevant stock certificates.
JD promotes three modes of operation:
- Franchising Business Partner – This module allow merchants to set up store in JD and get facility to use JD warehouse to stock their products. JD takes the full responsibility providing warehousing, delivery and customer service.
- Licensing Business Partner – Merchants may set up store and complete packaging in order to ship the order. JD will supervise customer service and process invoice.
- Self Operation Partner – Merchants may sell on the JD platform, although warehousing and delivery must be handled by the merchants themselves.
Selling point: JD provides both the eCommerce platform and comprehensive packages for logistic and warehouse services. JD’s net revenues for the second quarter of 2015 were US$7.4 billion, an increase of 61 per cent year on year.
Warehouse: Merchants can use a warehouse service provided by JD through selected packages.
Logistics: Merchants can use a logistic service provided by JD through selected packages. JD’s 211 same-day and next-day delivery program covers 135 and 951 counties and districts, respectively.
- Security Deposit – RMB10,000 – RMB50,000, depending on product category.
- Technical Fee – RMB6000 per annum.
- Commission – 5-7 per cent, plus 0.85 per cent if the JD shipping service is used.
Suitable For: JD dominates the home, appliance and consumer electronics categories in China and therefore favours 3C products.
Yihaodian is China’s largest online retailer of food and beverages, stocking over 8 million SKUs. The platform is 100 per cent owned by US retail giant Walmart and is licensed to import food and beverage products directly from overseas. In 2013, Yihaodian sold approximately 250 million imported items, including one-third of all imported UHT milk sold online in China. With a similar logistics system to JD, Yihaodian owns seven warehouses and operates more than 200 distribution centers in 40 cities.
Yihaodian allows foreign enterprises to sell tax-free and to be exempt from China’s domestic product standards through ‘cross-border’ eCommerce. Enterprises are often free from VAT, license/permit and Chinese label requirements. The platform presents an exciting opportunity for fresh food and beverage exporters.
- Applicant must be a Chinese mainland-incorporated enterprise;
- Possess relevant tax registration certificate (either national tax or local tax);
- Current business license which passes annual inspection;
- Possess relevant trademark registration certificate or a notice of acceptance of application for trademark registration;
- Declaration of imported goods should be issued by China Customs within two years of application; and
- Inspection certificate issued by Entry-Exit Inspection and Quarantine Bureau within two years of application.
Feature Services: Yihaodian’s cross border eCommerce model enables foreign sales which are tax-free and exempt from China’s domestic product standards. This year Yihaodian set a Guinness World Record for selling 100 containers (2 million boxes) of imported milk in just 51.5 minutes.
Warehouse Service: Merchant must use a comprehensive warehouse service provided by Yihaodian.
Logistics: Merchant must use logistic service provided by Yihaodian.
- Security Deposit – No Technical Fee Refund Policy.
- Technical Fee – RMB500 per month.
- Commission – 1-10 per cent plus 1 per cent Alipay fee.
Suitable For: Yihaodian specialises in the sale of fresh food and beverages.
Future Outlook for Foreign Enterprises
There are several distinguishing factors that separate TMall Global, JD and Yihaodian and can help inform which is the most suitable for a China business venture. Richard Cant, director of Dezan Shira & Associates’ North America office, comments: “This comparison clearly reveals the increasingly bureaucratic nature of establishing a store on Tmall Global and highlights JD as an attractive alternative platform for foreign enterprises, complete with a logistics perk. While Yihaodian currently lacks a platform for foreigners without a presence in China, the site is well situated to claim a larger portion of China’s eCommerce market, owing to its unprecedented growth in the past five years and innovative use of augmented reality technology.”
* This article was first published on China Briefing.
Since its establishment in 1992, Dezan Shira & Associates has been guiding foreign clients through Asia’s complex regulatory environment and assisting them with all aspects of legal, accounting, tax, internal control, HR, payroll and audit matters. As a full-service consultancy with operational offices across China, Hong Kong, India and emerging ASEAN, we are your reliable partner for business expansion in this region and beyond.