Sainsbury’s management appeared unfazed after emerging as the underperforming grocer of the UK top four this quarter. Should investors be worried? In the short term, Sainsbury’s may struggle, but they have solid long term prospects.
Margins have dropped to 1.9 per cent and like-for-like sales increased by only 1.6 per cent which is poor when it is reportedly passing on inflation of 1.7 per cent. All the other major supermarkets performed above expectations, even the floundering ASDA moved into positive like-for-likes after 12 consecutive quarters of negative growth.
The theme within the food retail sector has been one of anticipating inflation, moving to offset the impact on margins with cost savings programmes and range manipulation, along with efficiency targets. This has resulted in relatively stable margins for the majority of the grocers, alongside impressive cost reduction, and the best sales growth for five years. Sainsbury’s is therefore the anomaly here.
This can mean one of two things: Sainsbury’s is struggling more than the other grocers to weather the storm; or Sainsbury’s is less short-term focused than the other grocers and thus playing the long game.
Muted sales growth and a lack of evidence for the momentum from the first quarter continuing into the second (Q1 like-for-likes were 2.3 per cent and Q2 0.6 per cent) is problematic for Sainsbury’s, and with its positioning as a more premium grocer, consumers trading down in store and to cheaper competitors is more pertinent. However, they are still growing and the poor weather has a strong effect this quarter due to its high proportion of fresh food.
If we look at the factors eating into Sainsbury’s profit, we can see that it comes from (in order of size) price investment, input cost inflation, and Argos losses (Argos posted a loss in the first-half year, making most of its profit over the festive period). Ignoring Argos losses, the contributors to margin decline are therefore factors which all other supermarkets are experiencing.
The other grocers implemented strict cost saving programmes and margin targets in the run-up to Brexit. Tesco, for example, expects 3.5-4 per cent operating margin by 2019/20 and is seeking to achieve £1.5 billion of cost savings in its turnaround period. Morrisons is in full transformation mode with a number of efficiency savings still to take advantage of, and Asda is potentially recovering from a dismal three years. However, as much as many of these changes were needed, there is the risk that the other grocers are damaging their prospects in the long term by maintaining momentum in the short term. Lower investment and more short cuts, refurbishment, aggressive consolidation, a lack of development, and focus on cash flow might hamper the chances of long term growth. Short term gains may cause long term pain.
Sainsbury’s did not suffer to the same extent as the other grocers from the onslaught of the discounters, and thus has less to turnaround from. Therefore, as it survived through one difficult period, we think that its lack of action is actually a tactic. Sainsbury’s is highly focused on adapting to consumer consumption trends – its product innovation and range consolidation is unrivalled, same day delivery is being extended, and space repurposing has been successful with Argos. In addition, in the first half of 2017/18 it chose to absorb much of the cost inflation without offsetting it against efficiency savings, thus dragging on margins, and allegedly this level of investment is unlikely to happen again.
Fundamentally, Sainsbury’s needs to improve its growth in the third quarter to avoid losing market share, but one bad quarter hasn’t prompted them to “chase unprofitable volume” as Mike Coupe put it. We have confidence that Sainsbury’s is adapting to the consumer the best out of all of the supermarkets, but the problem is that its niche is slightly more upmarket than the others of the big four, and thus in a time of critical uncertainty, without offsetting, margins are going to take a temporary hit.
Sainsbury’s management know the company is well placed to chase the consumer and develop with demand, and thus we think that this strategy of allowing margin decline (within reason) is actually more of a tactical long term play, than disguising short term panic.
- Molly Johnson-Jones is a senior retail analyst with GlobalData.